Share with picklers

Shares

The Day I Stopped Being a Kind Pickleball Player

Ink sketch of a sad woman sitting alone at the end of a green Picklepedia bench, holding her pickleball paddle limply

By Picklepedia Contributor Alice Fenwick

I used to put my paddle in the rack and play whoever came up. I was new, and the rack was how I got a game. I would step on court and soon be congratulating strangers on shots we had barely meant to hit. You could arrive alone and, briefly, not be.

Then came a few mornings when that arrangement seemed less reliable. I would wait my turn and watch a group confer before returning to the court together. Sometimes there was a look, a pause, the small embarrassment of realizing an invitation had not really been extended. Nobody needed to be cruel. I stood beside my paddle, excluded from something advertised as open.

The worst part was how little there was to object to. Nobody had insulted me. A group had simply decided they preferred one another’s company, which was their right, except that I had understood the arrangement differently. I went home wondering whether I had misread the room, or whether the room had changed while I was standing in it.

That was not when I became less kind. It happened later, after I had improved, when I found myself doing the thing I had once resented.

The Small Town

I cannot say there was ever a golden age of pickleball courtesy. When I first started, everybody looked more experienced than I was. A player who could serve consistently impressed me. I was grateful to be included, even when we lost badly.

I didn’t have much choice about partners. Whoever was waiting became my partner, and that seemed normal. Some were patient with me. Others were visibly frustrated, although most managed to hide it until I missed a third shot in a row.

As I improved, I began to know people. I found partners whose movements I understood and whose company I enjoyed. I started looking forward to particular games. I also started feeling disappointed when I was paired with someone less experienced. I didn’t like admitting that, even to myself.

It wasn’t just about winning. I liked playing at a faster pace. I liked having a partner who knew where to stand without being reminded. There was nothing unreasonable about those preferences. The problem was that I began carrying them into sessions where everyone was supposed to get a turn.

The Rack

At an open-play court, the rack is supposed to make things simple. You put your paddle in and wait until your group is called. Four paddles go up together, and those four players take the next available court.

I remember the morning clearly. I had finished a game and was standing near the rack. My paddle grip was damp, and I was trying to smooth down a loose edge of tape. There was a paper cup on the bench. A player I didn’t recognize came over and put a paddle into an empty slot.

They looked at the paddles, then at the courts, and waited. I could tell they were new to the session because they kept checking the rack to see what would happen next.

Two friends were finishing a game. Another was standing beside me. We wanted to play together. Rather than join the newcomer’s paddle and fill the next group, I held on to mine. When my friends came off, we placed our four paddles together for a later turn. The newcomer’s paddle stayed where it was, waiting for three others.

I remember feeling relieved that our game was arranged. I also remember looking back at the single paddle. The player was still there, watching the courts. I could have explained the rotation or offered to join them. I didn’t.

That was the day I stopped being kind. Nobody would have noticed. I barely did.

Nobody teaches you to leave someone out. You learn it by being left out, and then one morning you are the four.

We played our game. I enjoyed it. That bothered me when I thought about it later.

After that I began noticing similar things about myself. I checked the rack before putting my paddle in. I was slower to agree to games with certain people. I still said hello and congratulated opponents on good shots. I could be friendly during a game while privately hoping not to be asked to play another.

I had once been irritated by players who made stacking seem like an entrance requirement. I still think the open-play stacking snob makes recreational play unnecessarily difficult. But I have become less comfortable judging people for being selective, because I have been doing it myself.

The Number

I understand why people want games with players of similar ability. I want them too. Ratings are useful for organizing those sessions, even if they measure something narrower than the faith we place in them.

What troubles me is how quickly a rating becomes a qualification at open play. I have done my share of this. I have asked about people’s levels before asking their names. Once, after being paired with a weaker player, I spent the first few points thinking about how much better the game would have been with someone else. I wasn’t playing particularly well myself. I have seen ordinary open play become too competitive, and I have contributed to it.

The Line

The same habit followed me into line calls. I used to think I was quite good about them. If I wasn’t sure a ball was out, I gave the point to my opponents. I still believe that is the right thing to do.

But after a few games in which close calls seemed to go against me, I started remembering them. Once I had decided other people were being careless with me, I gave myself permission to be less careful with them. During later games, I caught myself preparing to dispute calls before I had a good reason.

I haven’t become someone who deliberately calls balls out when they are in. But I have become more suspicious. I sometimes assume an opponent is taking advantage of me when they may simply have seen the ball differently. I doubt I’m particularly enjoyable to play against when I’m like that.

There is a reason the most dangerous word in pickleball causes so many arguments. Nobody wants to believe they are being unfair, especially when they are certain the other person was unfair first.

John Zakour puts it simply in his guide to positive pickleball etiquette: “don’t be a jerk.”

I wish I could say I always meet that standard. I have sighed when a partner missed an easy shot. I have offered advice that wasn’t requested. Sometimes I hear myself sounding impatient and then spend the next point wondering whether the other person noticed. Usually, I think they probably did.

The Net

I still like pickleball. Most mornings I enjoy the people I play with, and I leave feeling better than when I arrived. I don’t believe the courts are full of unkind people. I have met plenty who are generous with their time and willing to include somebody new.

I remember being grateful for those players when I started. A stranger would invite me into a game or explain where I should stand. Sometimes we played badly and laughed about it. Friendships in this sport can form fast, and I wouldn’t have many of mine if other people had been as selective as I am now.

I don’t expect to return to the way I was when I started. I enjoy playing with people who challenge me, and I still want those games. But I used to think I would never become one of those players who looked past someone waiting at the rack. I was wrong.

The other morning I finished a game and went to put my paddle away. There was one paddle in the rack, and its owner was waiting nearby. I recognized a couple of friends on the next court and would have liked to play with them. I put my paddle beside the newcomer’s anyway.

I didn’t feel especially generous. I wondered whether the game would be any good. Then I sat down to wait with them.

A friendly sport is measured by the fifth.